If you’re paying $100 or more every month for a prescription, you’re not alone. Thousands of Medicare Part D beneficiaries are stuck with high copays for medications that work for them - not because the drug is expensive, but because it’s on the wrong tier. The good news? You can fight back with a tier exception. It’s not a secret loophole. It’s a formal right built into your insurance plan. And when done right, it can cut your monthly drug bill by 70%, 80%, even 100%.
What Is a Tier Exception?
Your Medicare Part D or private drug plan puts medications into tiers - like levels in a pricing game. Tier 1 is the cheapest. Tier 2 is a bit more. Tier 3? That’s where many brand-name drugs land. Tier 4 and 5? Those are specialty drugs that can cost hundreds or even over a thousand dollars a month. You pay a fixed copay for each tier, not the full price.A tier exception is your request to move a drug from a higher tier to a lower one - even if it’s not the plan’s preferred choice. For example: your drug is on Tier 4 with a $150 copay. You ask for a tier exception to move it to Tier 2, where the copay is $30. If approved, you save $120 a month. That’s $1,440 a year. And it’s not just for Medicare. Most private plans use the same system.
Important: This isn’t the same as a formulary exception. A formulary exception is when you ask to get a drug that’s not on the plan’s list at all. A tier exception is when the drug is already covered - you just want it on a cheaper tier.
Why Do Tiers Exist?
Drug plans use tiers to save money. They negotiate lower prices with manufacturers for certain drugs and reward patients who pick those. The drugs they like best go on Tier 1 or 2. These are usually generics or brands with big rebates. The ones they don’t push as hard? They put on Tier 3 or higher. That doesn’t mean they’re worse. It just means the plan didn’t get a good deal on them.For example, two drugs might treat the same condition - say, rheumatoid arthritis. One is a brand-name biologic that costs $4,000 a month, but the plan got a 60% rebate. That drug might be on Tier 2. Another biologic, just as effective, costs the same but the plan didn’t negotiate a deal. That one ends up on Tier 4. Your doctor might need the second one because your body reacts poorly to the first. That’s where the tier exception comes in.
When Do You Need a Tier Exception?
You should consider a tier exception if:- You’re paying more than $50 a month for a drug you’ve been taking for months or years
- Your doctor says a cheaper alternative won’t work for you
- You’ve had side effects from drugs on lower tiers
- Your drug is a specialty medication (like for MS, cancer, or autoimmune diseases)
- You’re in the coverage gap (donut hole) and want to avoid paying 25% of the full price
People often wait until they get the bill. Don’t. The best time to request a tier exception is right after your doctor writes the prescription - before you fill it. That way, you avoid paying the high price upfront.
How to Get a Tier Exception Approved
There are three steps - and only one of them is yours.- Your doctor writes a letter. This is the most important part. The insurance company doesn’t care what you think. They care what your doctor says. The letter must explain why lower-tier drugs won’t work. Use specific language: "Patient developed gastrointestinal bleeding on Warfarin, requiring a switch to Apixaban due to increased risk of hemorrhage." Not: "Patient doesn’t like the other drugs."
- Your doctor fills out the form. Most plans have a standard tier exception form. Your doctor’s office should have it. If not, call your insurance company and ask for the form. Some plans let you download it online.
- Submit the request. Your doctor’s office can submit it for you. Or you can submit it yourself through your plan’s website or phone line. Keep a copy of everything.
Don’t skip the letter. A 2023 Medicare Rights Center survey found that 63% of denied requests failed because the clinical justification was too vague. Insurance reviewers look for three things:
- The preferred drug would be less effective
- The preferred drug would cause serious side effects
- Both
Be specific. Mention past reactions, hospitalizations, lab results. If you’ve tried the cheaper drug and it failed, say so. That’s gold.
What Happens After You Submit?
Plans have 72 hours to respond if your doctor says your health is at risk. Otherwise, they have 14 days. You’ll get a letter or email saying yes, no, or asking for more info.If you’re denied, don’t give up. About 78% of appeals get approved when you add more details. You can appeal in writing. Include any new medical records, test results, or even a second doctor’s note.
Real example: One patient in Toronto was denied for Humira because the plan said Enbrel was preferred. But the patient had tried Enbrel and developed a severe rash. The doctor resubmitted with photos and lab results showing immune markers. Approved on appeal. Copay dropped from $150 to $45.
Success Rates and Real Savings
CMS data shows that 62% of tier exception requests get approved the first time - if they’re complete. Only 31% get approved if the documentation is weak. That’s a huge difference.Patients who win their requests save an average of $37.50 per fill. For a monthly drug, that’s $450 a year. Some save more. Moving from Tier 4 ($100) to Tier 1 ($10) saves $90 a month - $1,080 a year. One Reddit user moved Humira from Tier 4 to Tier 3 and saved $105 a month. Another got Xarelto moved from Tier 3 to Tier 2 - saved $25 a month. Even $25 adds up.
Dr. Jane Smith from Kaiser Family Foundation says only 18% of eligible patients even try. That means most people pay more than they have to - just because they didn’t know it was possible.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Waiting to ask. Fill the prescription first? You’ll pay the high price. Then you’ll have to ask for a refund - which is messy.
- Letting the pharmacy handle it. Pharmacists can’t write medical justifications. Only your doctor can.
- Using vague language. "I can’t afford it" or "I don’t like the side effects" won’t cut it. You need clinical proof.
- Assuming one drug is always cheaper. Sometimes, a different drug in the same class might be on a lower tier. Ask your doctor: "Is there another option on Tier 2 that might work?" But if the answer is no - push for the exception.
What’s Changing in 2025?
Starting in 2025, the Inflation Reduction Act caps out-of-pocket drug costs at $2,000 a year for Medicare Part D beneficiaries. That’s huge. But it doesn’t eliminate tier exceptions. Why? Because that cap applies to your total spending - not your monthly copay. If your drug is on Tier 4, you’re still paying more each month than someone on Tier 2. That means you’ll hit the $2,000 cap faster. And if you’re in the coverage gap, a lower tier means you pay less during that phase.Also, more plans are rolling out automated tools. UnitedHealthcare now lets doctors check approval chances before submitting. That cuts approval time from 9 days to under 4. More plans will follow.
What If You Don’t Have Medicare?
You still qualify. Most private insurance plans - Blue Cross, Cigna, Aetna, etc. - use tiered formularies too. The rules are similar. Call your plan. Ask: "Do you have a tier exception process?" If they say no, ask for the formulary and see where your drug is listed. Then ask your doctor to request a lower tier.Even if you’re on Medicaid or a marketplace plan, ask. Many states and insurers have similar processes.
What to Do Next
1. Check your current copay. Look at your last prescription receipt. What tier is your drug on? 2. Call your plan. Ask: "What tier is [drug name] on? What’s the copay for Tier 1 and Tier 2?" 3. Talk to your doctor. Say: "I’m paying $X a month for this drug. Is there a way to get it on a lower tier? Can you help me request a tier exception?" 4. Submit the request before filling your next script. 5. Follow up. If you don’t hear back in 10 days, call again.It’s not magic. It’s paperwork. But it’s paperwork that saves real money. And if you’re taking a drug long-term, those savings add up fast.
Can I request a tier exception for any drug?
Yes - but only if the drug is already on your plan’s formulary. You can’t use a tier exception to get a drug that’s completely excluded. For that, you need a formulary exception. Tier exceptions only move a covered drug to a lower cost tier.
Do I need a letter from my doctor every time?
No. Once approved, the lower tier stays in place for the rest of the year - or until your plan changes its formulary. You won’t need to reapply unless you switch plans or your doctor changes your medication.
What if my doctor refuses to help?
Some doctors are overwhelmed. If your doctor won’t help, ask for a nurse practitioner or pharmacy liaison at the clinic. Many offices have staff trained to handle these requests. You can also call your plan’s member services - they often have templates you can give your doctor to make it easier.
Can I get a tier exception for an over-the-counter drug?
No. Tier exceptions only apply to prescription drugs covered under your plan. Over-the-counter medications are not included in Medicare Part D or most private plans unless prescribed and dispensed through a pharmacy.
How long does a tier exception last?
Once approved, the lower copay applies for the rest of the plan year. If you switch plans next year, you’ll need to reapply. Some plans renew approvals automatically if your condition hasn’t changed - but always check with your insurer.
Is there a limit to how many tier exceptions I can request?
No. You can request a tier exception for every medication you take that’s on a higher tier. Many people have 2 or 3 drugs that qualify. Each one can save you hundreds per year.
Write a comment